Gas detector tubes

Gas detector tubes (and some relevant industrial standards)

GASTEC gas detector tubes are thin glass tubes with calibration scales printed on them so you can directly read concentrations of the substances (gases and vapours) to be measured. Each tube contains a particulate matrix (e.g. silica gel, alumina) which binds carefully selected and highly stable detection reagents that are especially sensitive to the target substance in order to produce a distinct layer of colour change. The tubes are hermetically sealed at both ends.

Today over 600 types of target gas can be measured.


Features

The handy design GASTEC GV-100 cylinder pump, with an inner capacity of 100mL, weighs only 240g. It is designed for use with almost all GASTEC short-term quick-measuring detector tubes.

Relevant industrial standards

In Japan, there initially were no designated industrial standards for detector tubes besides industrial standard JIS M 7605/JIS M 7650 for carbon-monoxide detectors (originally developed to ensure mining safety) and certain other standards pertaining to specific gas analysis (e.g. exhaust gas measurement, or for impurities in compressed air or household gas in pressure cylinders, etc.) that also apply to certain detector tubes. It was not until 1985, that a comprehensive standard that regulates detector tubes was established: JIS K 0804. This standard applies to all concentration (%) based measuring equipment for use in work environments (so it is not limited to detector tubes) and is unprecedented in its comprehensiveness.

Other standards

Of course, there exist many other standards pertaining to detector tubes, for instance, British standard BS5343, German standard DIN33882 or the international standard of IUPAC (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry). However, these all deal primarily with the immediate working environment and do not go so far as the JIS standards in regulating actual process control. The following table provides an overview and comparison of the aforementioned standards.

Comparison of major international industrial standards
  Performance requirements /
name of standard
JIS K 0804 BS5343 lUPAC ANSl / ISEA
102-1990
Sampling pump Volume (capacity) +/-5% +/-5% +/-5% +/-5%
Air tightness 3% or max. 3%/min. - max. 3%/min. max. 3%/min.
Air intake rate Deviation in inner storage capacity
+/-10%
- - -
Durability must still satisfy above requirement after 100 consecutive pump strokes - - Deviation in holding capacity after 10 consecutive pump strokes
+/-5%
Detector tube vertical spread in detection reagent max.2mm max.1mm max.2mm max.2mm
Dispersion in tip of colour change max.20% max.20% max.20% max.20%
Indicability 1 at least 1/3 of calibrated scale
read value +/-25%
mean value +/-15%
MPC
+30 to -20%
1, 2, or 5 x MPC
+/-25%
1, 2, or 5 x MPC
+/-25%
2 max. 1/3 of calibrated scale
read value +/-35%
mean value +/-25%
0.5, 2 x MPC
+50 to -20%
0.5 x MPC
+/-35%
0.5 x MPC
+/-35%
Length of discolouration - min.15mm min.15mm min.15mm

Notes
BSI : British Standard Institution
BS5343F1976 Gas Detector Tubes
lUPAC : International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry
Performance Standard for Detector Tube Unitsused to monitor gases
and vapours in working areas
ANSl / ISEA : American National Standards
Institute Industrial Safety Equipment Association

Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page


SEI certification

GASTEC detector tubes satisfy the quality standards and norms in the world.

The SEI certification program is well known as one of the most stringent certification programs. We are proud of having the highest number of SEI certified detector tubes worldwide.
SEIFSafety Equipment Institute(U.S.A)

SEI certification

SEI stands for Safety Equipment Institute, a private nonprofit organization established in 1981 in the USA to administer the first non-government third-party certification program for testing and certification of a broad range of occupational safety and protective products. In 1986, it established a national certification system for detector tubes which succeeded and enhanced the existing NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health) certification program. The SEI certification program is accredited by the American National Standards Institute [ANSI] and utilises the ANSI^ISEA l02 American National Standard for Gas Detector Tubes - Short Term Type for Toxic Gases and vapours in Working Environments.

The certification process is stringent and objective as the examination and auditing process for the products and manufacturing facilities is conducted through independent third-parties who are specialists in the field. Currently SEI certifies 21 detector tubes for 21 types of gases/vapours.

SEI certification requirements
  1. Four point indication accuracy of gas concentration is required: +/-35% at 0.5 x the testing standard concentration and +/-25% at 1 x, 2 x, and 5 x respectively. The TLV (Threshold Limit Value) of the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) is designated as the testing standard concentration.
  2. The length of the discolouration (i.e. colour stain) for the designated concentration should be at least 15mm with a maximum standard deviation of 10% permissible in the values as read by three different individuals.
  3. Any slant (inclination) of the discolouration (i.e. colour stain) tip should not exceed 20%.
  4. Any void or notch between the detection reagent and the matrix holding it in place should not exceed 2mm.
  5. The intake (aspiration) capacity of a gas sampling pump should be within a standard deviation of +/-5% of the requirement. Any leakage should not exceed 3% per minute.
  6. In addition, the content of any instruction sheet(s) or label(s) for the product in question are stipulated.
The NIOSH certification program

The acronym NIOSH stands for the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (of the United States). In 1972, NIOSH established what is widely considered to be the worldfs first official national certification system for detector tubes. In fact, this groundbreaking initiative to bring clarity to the disparate maze of certification norms and procedures relating to detector tubes by creating a unified certification basis (including on-site manufacturing facility quality-assurance auditing standards) was the precursor of the SEI certification for detector tube systems.

Both long-term measurement and direct colour-change reading/comparison detector tubes (as well as the ancillary sampling pumps) for a total of 23 types of target gases/vapours were subject to certification/testing after which all approved and certified products were officially publicised. During eight years of certification testing, 63 types of detector tubes successfully passed the NIOSH requirements and were officially certified (NIOSH certification ended in 1983). The effectiveness and efficiency of the NIOSH certification program is evident from the fact that only four (4) of 23 tested detector tube types were actually certified in the pre-NIOSH period.


NIOSHFNational Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (U.S.A)

Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page


Gas sampling methods
Vacuum

Most widely used in the world for gas detector tube systems. Sample air is aspirated (drawn) into the detector tube manually by pulling the handle of the sampling pump (that the detector tube is inserted in). It can be easily and quickly used by anyone anywhere.

Injection

Used for some gas detector tube systems. The air sample is first drawn into a syringe before being injected into the detector tube. There are numerous high-concentration measuring applications of this type available for carbon dioxide, propane, etc.

*Using the injection method
Sampling pump

Used for both gas detector tube systems and sensor systems. Sample air is automatically aspirated by the motor driven pump at a prescribed rate for a prescribed time. The GASTEC GSP series automatic gas samplers use this method.

Compressed air

This system is used to measure compressed air/gas from a compressor or other pressurised vessel. The compressed air is sampled by attaching a pressure reducing valve with flowmetre (between the vessel and the detector tube) in order to enable the pressurised air/gas inside the vessel to flow via the flowmetre into the detector tube at a fixed rate of flow for a predetermined time. It can be used to check for impurities in scuba-diving tanks or pressurised gas containers.

Diffusion

This method is used for some gas detector tube systems as well as sensor systems. Air is not aspirated by sampling pump but allowed to diffuse into a sensor or detector tube placed in a factory or laboratory environment . A diffuser accelerates the gas diffusion rate to produce a longer colour change layer and the mean value for a 1-10 hour period is obtained. GASTEC passive dosimeter tubes utilise this principle.

Vapour-liquid equilibrium

When a solution is put in a sealed container, any substances dissolved in it vapourise and diffuse until the concentration remaining in solution and the vapour equilibrate at a specific ratio that is unique to that substance: its specific vapour-liquid equilibrium.

To obtain the true concentration of the target substance in solution, simply draw the air into an appropriate detector tube with the GV-100 Gas Sampling Pump and read, and then either:

a.) multiply the reading by the correction factor unique to the specific target substance

 or

b.) correct the reading by using the correction graph for the target substance.

Reagent-adding

A specific reagent is added to the sample to change the target substance into a gas that is easy to measure. A sample of generated gas is aspirated into an appropriate detector tube with the Model GV-100 Gas Sampling Pump. Tube readings should be corrected by multiplying by prescribed factors that are in a known proportionate ratio to one gram of said reagent.

Capillary tube

This method utilises capillary action which causes a sample liquid to rise up a narrow detector tube. With this method, measurements are quite simple.

The detector tube end is merely immersed vertically in the liquid sample (directional arrow pointing upward) and a reading is taken after the prescribed sampling time has elapsed. The GASTEC lineup includes a dissolved sulphide detector tube which can be used to detect sulphur ion (S2-) in water.

Liquid aspiration

This method entails the forced sampling of a liquid using a strong aspiration (suction) via a syringe with a filter and then extracting it with a dropper pipette through a detector tube. Using the indicated value (that is read) and a prescribed calculation factor the volume of the target substance contained (in the liquid sample) can then be extrapolated. This method is useful, for instance, when measuring the salinity of raw concrete or bulk aggregate.


Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page


GASTEC Quality Assurance

As the emphasis shifts from mere detection to precise measurement on the ppb (parts per billion) or 1/1000ppm scale, the users demand even better performance and the highest quality from their detector tube systems.

To satisfy these demands, GASTEC utilises a strict and comprehensive quality assurance program that involves all corporate levels from the planning and development to the production and inspection departments. Each department has its specific and stringent standard, and only products that have met all these standards are shipped.

The prerequisites for optimal performance

The four essential features of GASTECfs program are:

  1. Meticulous planning and development
    Key criteria are the substances to be measured, the measuring range and objective as well as the intended measurement environments. In development, never-ceasing efforts are made to produce a clear demarcation of colour change and to expand the measuring range of a detector tube beyond existing limits.
    Enhanced reagent stability
    Detector tube measurement utilises a chemical reaction of reagents with the target substance. Reagent stability may well determine the shelf life of a detector tube. At GASTEC, we have been endeavouring to develop reagents with still greater stability as well as striving to improve the quality of conventional reagents.
  2. Improved detector tube accuracy
    Advances in production technologies are greatly enhancing the accuracy of detector tubes. Today, important factors that may affect the accuracy of detector tube systems include inconsistent (inner) tube diameters or hampered flow of sampled air due to resistance of filling reagents and packing material.
  3. Accurate calibration gas generation
    A precise calibration scale is tantamount to the lifeline of a detector tube. Measurements with the most meticulously fabricated top-quality detector tube are useless, if the tube is not correctly and precisely calibrated as well. Ever since GASTEC was established, the calibration scale for all detector tubes of the same production lot is determined by sampling with a standard gas (whose concentration is precisely defined and regulated using the Companyfs proprietary technology).

Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page


Detector tube calibration gas

A precise standard calibration gas ensures precise measurements

Calibration gas

Precise calibration is the lifeline of a detector tube. GASTEC takes particular pride in the painstaking care it takes to keep any concentration fluctuations due to possible adherence of gas molecules to the inside of the storage or transfer vessels to an absolutely insignificant minimum. GASTEC is always on the cutting edge of new developments and technologies as it was quick to adopt innovative and accurate calibration gas generating methods such as the permeation tube or the gas diffusion tube principles. GASTEC is highly regarded also as a pioneer of calibration gas technology.

  1. Permeation tube
    A permeation tube is a sealed tube, that has a uniform inner diameter, is filled with a highly pure liquefied target gas, and is extremely stable.
    If the permeation tube is maintained at a fixed temperature in our proprietary calibration gas generating equipment, liquefied gas will permeate from the detector tube at a fixed flowrate. When this combines with a fixed quantity of dilution gas, calibration gas of the desired concentration is continuously generated.
  2. Diffusion tube
    A diffusion tube is a glass tube that consists of a liquid container and a diffuser with a uniform inner diameter. A pure and very stable target liquid is put into the liquid container using a glass syringe. If thes tube is kept at a constant temperature, the liquid evaporates and diffuses at a constant rate and mixes with the dilution gas whereby the calibration gas of the desired concentration is continuously generated.
  3. High pressure gas cylinder
    Calibration gases are supplied in high-pressure gas cylinders, which have been prepared in accordance with Japanese Industrial Standard JIS K0001 to K0007.
  4. Static dilution
    With this method, a prescribed amount of highly purified gas or liquid of the target substance is placed in a glass container (20 litres or more), and is diluted with air or nitrogen gas to generate the desired concentration of target gas.
  5. Dynamic dilution
    With this method, the flowrate of a precisely determined concentration of target gas and of the dilution gas are regulated to continuously generate the desired concentration of target gas.

Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page


Additional measuring knowhow
Standard aspiration (sampling) volume

Most detector tubes are calibrated for a sampling volume of 100mL. However, depending on the type of target gas, or the concentration, the volume should be changed to 50mL, 200mL, 300mL, or 500mL which necessitates the number of pump strokes to be changed accordingly. With 100mL being the standard sampling volume, a 500mL volume would require 5 strokes to obtain the correct volume. The detector tube label includes a chart which shows how many strokes are necessary for various sampling volumes.

Extension of the measuring range

For most GASTEC detector tubes, if the colour change layer exceeds or does not reach the calibration scale during measurements with standard sample volumes, the concentrations outside of the calibration scale can be measured by changing the sample volume accordingly.

When colour change layer does not reach calibration scale

Sampling is repeated until the discolouration stain reaches the minimum scale. Then the indicated value is read off the scale and divided by the number of strokes (or in some cases, multiplied by the correction factor to obtain the true concentration.

*Although in principle, the lowest concentration can be measured with a maximum of 10 full pump strokes, this number needs to be reduced in some cases to ensure accuracy. Please check the instruction manual "number of pump strokes [n]" before measuring.
When the colour change exceeds the calibration scale

Replace the tube with a fresh one, and sample with half of the standard volume. When the discolouration stain stays within the calibrated scale, the tube reading should be doubled (or in some cases, multiplied by the correction factor) to determine the true concentration.

*Although in principle, the highest concentration can be measured with a minimum of 0.5 pump strokes, this number needs to be increased in some cases to ensure accuracy. Please check the instruction manual "number of pump strokes [n]" before measuring.
Accuracy tolerance when using detector tubes

There can be slight deviations in values obtained even under the most ideal circumstances. There are a random errors which the detection pipe itself has in this variation, and recurring (systematic) errors attributable to the manufacturer or the operator conducting the measurement. Their respective characteristics are described below.

Random errors

Even when a sample of a definite concentration is measured with highly precise detector tubes, the results will fluctuate to some extent on both sides of the mean. This type of error is referred to as random. To evaluate random errors, the relative standard deviation is used, which shows (in percentages) how the reading deviates from the mean value. This value Is also called the coefficient of variation (CV).

Random errors can essentially be attributed to :

  1. fluctuations in the inner diameters of detector tubes, densities of filling reagents, or sensitivities of reagents
  2. the operators who read the tubes
Systematic errors

What is known as a systematic error can generally be attributed to the manufacture and/or the operator and it generally involves one or more of the following factors:

  1. leakage of sampling pump
  2. incorrectly calibrated detector tubes
  3. incorrect sampling time, inappropriate storage or usage of detector tubes
  4. presence of interferents
Reaction principles

Detector tubes generally employ one of the following three types of reaction principle:

  1. Direct reaction
    The target substance (to be measured) directly reacts with a detecting reagent
  2. Compound reaction
    The target substance instantaneously reacts with several detecting reagents within the detector tube
  3. Two-step reaction
    The substance is oxidised in the pretreatment layer before reacting with the detecting reagent itself
Effects of temperature

Among the many types of detector tubes, there are some that are more susceptible to the effects of temperature than others. This section introduces the effects of temperature variances as well as the correct response procedures.

Correction for temperature

All GASTEC detector tubes are calibrated based on a tube temperature (NOT sample temperature) of 20ºC (68ºF). Some tubes, however, are very sensitive and may not provide correct indications at temperatures other than 20ºC. If indications are affected more than+/-10%, tube readings should be corrected. The appropriate temperature correction values (or any other adjustment that may be required) are provided in the instruction sheet that comes with each detector tube package.

Temperature correction factors for 1,1,1-Trichloroethane detector tube(No.135)
Temperature 0ºC
(32ºF)
10ºC
(50ºF)
20ºC
(68ºF)
30ºC
(86ºF)
40ºC
(104ºF)
Correction factor 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.65
Temperature correction factors for Tetrachloeoethylene detector tube(No.133M)
Tube Reading
(ppm)
True concentration(ppm)
0ºC
(32ºF)
10ºC
(50ºF)
20ºC
(68ºF)
30ºC
(86ºF)
40ºC
(104ºF)
100 410 155 100 80 65
80 310 125 80 65 50
60 210 95 60 50 40
40 130 60 40 35 25
20 55 30 20 17 15
10 20 13 10 8 7
5 8 6 5 4 3
Effects of temperature variances

There are two basic types of phenomenon involving the effects of temperature:

  1. Effects on reaction rate:
    Generally chemical reaction rates are proportional to the temperature.
    As a rule of thumb: the lower the temperature falls, the slower the reaction rate becomes; and the higher the temperature, the quicker the reaction rate. Therefore, the occurrence of phenomenon (I.) (II.), can exert quite the opposite effect on the values indicated by the same detector tube type. Some of the GASTEC tube types susceptible to such influences are 6L, 13, 132M, 141.
    (1) When the temperature is lower than 20ºC (68ºF):
    Reaction will be slower and part of the sample will not react in the zone where reaction usually occurs at 20ºC (68ºF); but, a slight reaction may instead occur deeper in the tube. As a result, a longer stain of pale colour change is produced, giving a higher indication (i.e. reading).
    (2) When the temperature is higher than 20ºC (68ºF):
    Reaction will be quicker and accelerated so the sample may react ahead of the zone where reaction usually occurs at 20ºC (68ºF) in the tube. As a result, a shorter, albeit more intense, stain of distinct colour change is produced, giving a lower indication (i.e. reading).
  2. Effects on physical adsorption:
    Generally the quantity of physical adsorption of a certain substance to its reagent is inversely proportional to the temperature. At lower temperatures, some quantity of the substance will be physically adsorbed to the reagent that has already reacted with the preceding substance, and will not reach the usual reaction zone. As a result, only a short stain of colour change is produced, giving a lower indication. On the contrary, at higher temperatures, higher indications will be obtained. Some of the GASTEC tubes thus affected are 1La, 100B, 171.

*Tube temperature and sample temperature:
When air is sampled, its temperature instantly adapts to that of the detector tube. The term "temperature" when used for correction of tube readings refers to tube temperature, NOT sample temperature. If detector tubes are kept within a certain ambient temperature for a while, the tube temperature will adapt to the ambient temperature. Therefore, a detector tube just removed from cool storage (e.g. a refrigerator) is the same temperature as the storage itself, but it will gradually acclimatise to the ambient temperature.

Effects of humidity

Although, the vast majority of GASTEC detector tubes is not affected by a relative humidity in the range of 0 to 90%, some are susceptible to humidity. In the following section, both types of detector tubs will be discussed.

Moreover, when the relative humidity exceeds 100% (super saturation), water vapour in the air condenses, which dilutes concentrations of water-soluble gases (for instance, hydrogen chloride) and accurate results will not be obtained.

GASTEC detector tubes unaffected by humidity

There are two main reasons why detector tubes remain unaffected by humidity:

  1. When the detector tube uses a water-based reactant
    The reactant in the reagent matrix in the detecting tube is generally in the form of a water-based solution. In this case, the target gas and the reactant interact in an "air-liquid reaction" and although the resultant water vapour may dilute the concentration of the reagent, there is no adverse effect by humidity on the value indicated by the detector tube because the reactant remains in its liquid state and the absolute mass is not affected either.
    Typical water-based reactant detector tubes are 1LA, 2L, 4LL, 5LB, 8LA, 9LA.
  2. 2 When the detector tube uses concentrated sulphuric acid or a desiccant
    When the detector tube uses concentrated sulphuric acid as an oxidant, or when it contains a desiccant, water vapour tends to be absorbed so there is no adverse effect by humidity on the value indicated by the detector tube.
    Some of these detector tubes are 1H, 13, 14M, 71, 91, 122, 132L.
GASTEC detector tubes affected by humidity

Only five detector tubes are actually affected by humidity. Detector tubes No. 15L, 17, and 185 are calibrated for a relative humidity of 50%; No. 137 and 138 are calibrated for an absolute humidity of 10mg/L. The aforementioned tube types require a correction for humidity, similar to the correction for temperature. Humidity correction coefficients are provided in the instruction sheets for these detector tubes 15L, 17, 137, 138, 185.

Effects of atmospheric pressure

Generally the gas concentration is proportional to the pressure. All GASTEC detector tubes are calibrated based on normal atmospheric pressure (1013hPa or 760 mmHg) and their indications will not be affected over the range of +/- 10% of normal pressure, that is 912 to 1114hPa or 684 to 836 mmHg. When the pressure at the time of measurement is not in this range, the tube reading should be corrected as follows:

Factors that cause atmospheric pressure to have an effect

Generally the gas concentration is proportional to the pressure. All GASTEC detector tubes are calibrated based on normal atmospheric pressure (1013hPa or 760 mmHg) and their indications will not be affected over the range of +/- 10% of normal pressure, that is 912 to 1114hPa or 684 to 836 mmHg. When the pressure at the time of measurement is not in this range, the tube reading should be corrected as follows:

Measures to correct/offset effects of atmospheric pressure

For instance, the indicated value needs to be corrected when the atmospheric pressure at 1000 meters ASL (above sea level) and the civil engineering work (pneumatic method) at high atmospheric pressure diverge. The correction formula is as follows:

= Actual tube reading x 1013 (hPa) / Measured atmospheric pressure (hPa)

Interference gases (interferents)

When a gas with similar characteristics to the target object gas is present during sampling, it will affect the measurement. These gases which are referred to as interferents affect the accuracy of any tube reading. Some of the common interferents are described below.

Interference in direct-reading detector tubes
  1. The reagent(s) will also react to interferents, giving a higher indication. An example of such an interferent is Hydrogen Sulphide to the Hydrogen Cyanide detector tube (No.12L).
  2. If a pH indicator is contained in the tube, acids and bases will react as interferents, giving a higher indication. An example of such an interferent is Hydrogen chloride to the Hydrogen cyanide detector tube (No.12L).
Compound reaction / Interference in two-step reaction type detector tubes
  1. When the substances that result from the chemical reaction are identical to the target gas, a higher value (than the actual concentration) will be indicated.
    An example of such an interferent is tetrachloroethylene to detector tube 132L.
  2. Because the oxidant reacts with the interferent, the inherent oxidation rate is insufficient, and the indicated value will be lower.
    An example of such an interferent is aromatic hydrocarbons to detector tube 132L.
Safekeeping and Storage of GASTEC gas detector tubes

In principle, the accuracy of detector tubes can be maintained for a longer time in low temperatures; we recommend dark refrigerated storage at 0 to 10KC (32 to 50KF) and direct sunlight should be avoided at all times. Be sure to always keep them in a safe place out of the reach of children's eyes and hands.

Disposal of detector tubes

Detector tubes contain chemical reagents that may include substances subject to laws and regulations requiring specific disposal procedures.

Therefore, a detector tube that has been used (or whose expiration date has passed) should be disposed of in accordance with the relevant disposal regulations valid in your area or jurisdiction. For further information contact your local distributor or GASTEC representative.


Further details on detector tube disposal here

Return to previous viewReturn to listGo to top of page